Ruth Smith Law Firm FOCUSED ON Personal Injury and Disability LAW
CALL FOR A Free Consultation
Call 828-782-3832

North Carolina HB 239: Politics In The Court Of Appeals

North Carolina HB 239 is an effort by the North Carolina State Legislature to play politics with the North Carolina Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals is the intermediary appeals state court. Since the N.C. Supreme Court can deny hearing cases, the last appeal for many cases is the N.C. Court of Appeals. Currently, the Court of Appeals has a huge case load: 1500 appeals and 4,456 separate petitions and motions per year. Currently the Court of Appeals has fifteen judges who sit on three judge panels. The average number of opinions per judge is 100 opinions per year. In an effort to deny Governor Roy Cooper the ability to appoint judges, the North Carolina Republican-controlled legislature has passed North Carolina HB 239. (HB 239).


North Carolina HB 239 Restricts The Governor's Judicial Appointments

Under previous law, if a judge's seat became vacant before a term expired, the governor could appoint a replacement until the next election. Under HB239, the seat would simply remain vacant until the Court was whittled down to 12 seats.

Three judges are set to retire during Governor Cooper's term due to their reaching the mandatory retirement age. The HB239 strips Governor Cooper from naming the replacements for these seats.

The number of seats on the N.C. Court of Appeals has never been reduced in the history of the Court. The workload of the Court is expected to increase, as more appeals are coming from the N.C. Industrial Commission, the body that hears all workers' compensation claims in North Carolina. In 2016, the General Assembly stripped the governor of the ability to appoint certain judges to the Industrial Commission. This resulted in a Commission that has been seen as mostly pro-employer.

HB 239's sponsor, Rep. Justin Burr (R- Montgomery, Stanly) denied that the bill was introduced for the purpose of restricting Governor Cooper's power. However, the bill was one of several that Burr introduced (HB240, HB 241) in a recent flurry that seeks to limit Governor Cooper's powers. These bills strip the governor from appointing judges to vacant seats in individual judicial districts.

Former N.C. Court of Appeals justices have spoken out against the proposed change, as they note that the Court of Appeals is already overworked. Both judges and attorneys worry that by reducing the number of judges to hear appeals, citizens will have to wait even longer for opinions as their cases slowly work through a congested court system. Additionally, Judge Douglas McCullogh, a Republican and member of the Court of Appeals, resigned his seat in protest over the change.

The bipartisan Public Trust and Confidence Committee of North Carolina Commission on the Administration of Law and Justice, convened by Chief Justice Mark Martin (R), passed a resolution in 2016 urging the General Assembly "to tie the number of judges and justices on a given court to the workload of the relevant court". The legislature ignored this resolution in passing HB 239.

The bill passed the legislature and was vetoed by Governor Cooper. The General Assembly overrode the veto on April 26, 2017 and the bill is now law. Thus, N.C. citizens will likely have their cases delayed as politicians play politics with North Carolina's court system.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Find Out How We Can Help Today!

When you have been injured by someone else's carelessness or negligence, you want help. Dealing with doctors, insurers, lawyers and courts can be overwhelming at a time when you are hurt and simply want to feel better again.

That's where Ruth can help. She understands claims' procedures, court filing deadlines and what you need to do to begin your recovery and protect your rights. Call for a free initial consultation at 828-782-3832 or use our convenient online form and we will get in touch with you. While based in Asheville, Ruth Smith serves clients across North Carolina and South Carolina.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy


Ruth Smith Law Firm Personal Injury and Disability LAW

68 N Market Street
Asheville, NC 28801

Phone: 828-782-3832
Fax: 828-255-8693
Asheville Law Office Map

CALL FOR A Free Consultation